?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

The Technical Library sub forum will contain how-to and reference articles for all generations of the FJR1300.
Forum rules
13.B - For tech library threads, same approach as the merchandise threads – all posts will be related to the tech library topic – questions about the topic, posts adding to the topic from a technical perspective, etc. Any posts outside of those will be deleted by forum moderators or admins.
dcarver
Contributor
Veteran
Posts: 1018
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2013 12:18 am
FJRModel: Gen2, Superior 2006, Gen 3 2013 twice as good!
x 120
x 1542

?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by dcarver »

Ok, ok you forced my hand. I'm posting about bench testing ignition coils from a 1979 KZ1300 not an FJR. But both platforms use a 'wasted spark' ignition system so commonality exists. :bustinlove:

Installed new YellowSquare ignition coils. Bike still didn't run good.
Ground plugs to valve cover, crank engine, hmm, maybe I kinda sorta spark but not like WOW, look at THAT!

Time to bench test the coils.

Search Google. Find this. Ez pz.

Batt + to coil +
Coil neg to switch to batt neg
Ground spark plug(s) shank to Batt neg
Connect both spark plugs shank together (wasted spark systems require this connection)
Hi tension leads to sparkplug caps

Close then Open switch, primary field collapses, induces hi voltage in secondary, discharges through plug.

But. It doesn't work. No spark.

WTFO? Not likely all coils are bad. Must be test set up.

Check all wires for continuity
Check plug resistance
Check switch
Everything checked out SAT

Got to thinking. Auto ignition coils use a condenser to prevent premature point pitting - due to high voltage induced into points. The condenser blocks that voltage.

Installed a condenser and voila, spark.
Image
Image

Question 1
What I don't know is why adding the condenser enables plugs to spark. Could it be the switch, as it opens the primary to induce field collapse and 2ndry discharge is discharging though the switch contact?


Don't find answer about condenser. But in doing research, find *one* reference that weak / no spark can be result of coil primary over saturation. The KZ has 8000 rpm redline. 8000/60 means a spark event (build up primary EMF, open circuit collapse field, induce secondary, discharge spark) has to occur every 7.5 milliSeconds. That's FAST!

A typical spark duration is ~1.3 milliSeconds. Sooo, the primary has to establish full field in 7.5 mS minus the 1.2mS for spark duration which equals 6.3 mS.

Obviously, I can't toggle the switch that breaks the primary negative side faster than about once per second. Meaning the primary flux is over saturated.

Question 2
What I don't know (a LOT :lol: ) is how severe the high voltage degradation is given an over saturated primary?

Research revealed this beauty, a Hall effect pulse width modulator that can test devices requiring a pulse - stepper motors, fuel injectors AND ignition coils. It's coming from <gasp> China on a slow boat.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0CZ84R1JC?ps ... ct_details

[youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ONyoQfe6ngA[/youtube]

Hoping someone a whole lot 'fart smeller' than me can chime in with facts, ideas, thoughts.

I know, it's a technical rant. But it's real to me! :zombwobb:

For the complete diatribe...
https://candybuttorg.ipage.com/cba/node/1430
wheatonFJR loved this
User avatar
Red
Veteran
Posts: 939
Joined: Mon Mar 31, 2014 11:09 am
FJRModel: 2008 FJR1300A
Location: near the Great Salt Lake, Utah, USA, Sol III, Orion Spur of the Milky Way galaxy.
x 212
x 1150

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by Red »

dcarver,

From what I know of inductors (coils), over-saturation should not have much (if any) effect on spark.
The condenser (capacitor) just protects the contact points from arcing damage, whether inside an old car or your manual switch.
Electrical potential is measured in Volts.
Power is measured in Watts.
Resistance is measured in Ohms.
Inductance is best measured in Henries, for any coil. A less certain coil measurement can be done in Ohms, but that can be deceiving.
(Each standard is named in honor of the guy known for research on that aspect of electrical theory.)

All that to say this: measure a new or known good coil with a Henry meter. They are rare, but a good electronics shop might have one.
The Henries values of the primary coil and the secondary coil will be very different, but should match the measurements of a known good unit.
Coils generally fail by internal shorting, changing the Henries values you measure, until the coil goes open-circuit internally
Partially shorted primaries will change the spark voltage, but may lessen the duration.
Partially shorted secondaries will reduce the spark voltage.
The bench test rig you have is a quick-and-dirty Go/Nogo level of testing. It really won't tell you much about the internal condition of the coils, unless they are already dying.
FWIW, I would look into the coil-over-plug mod, if I even suspected that I had bad coils in my bike. You only send low-Voltage pulses to each plug, with the coil-over-plug mod. High-tension wiring is eliminated.
HTH.
dcarver loved this
Cheers,
Red

P.S. Life is too short, and health is too valuable, to ride on cheap parade-duty tires.
Yeah, I ride motorcycles. I know why dogs put their heads out of the car windows.
Yeah, I fly hang gliders (3000 hrs.+). I know why the birds sing.
User avatar
raYzerman
Contributor
I post more than I ride
Posts: 9573
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 10:49 am
FJRModel: 2010 Honda CBF1000FA
Location: Millgrove, Ontario, CA
x 3085
x 11377

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by raYzerman »

Don't know anything.... but assuming the KZ does not have a condenser or points ignition, like an old Honda I just got.
Question, you've got the wires directly to the plugs...... are there not spark plug adapters, and don't they have a resistance of like 5k ohms?? I don't know if that is an issue or not.......
Keep yer stick on the ice........... (Red Green)
Duct tape can't fix stupid, but it can sure muffle the sound.
N4HHE
Veteran
Posts: 2152
Joined: Thu Mar 08, 2018 10:17 pm
FJRModel: 2016
Location: North Alabama
x 3611
x 1975

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by N4HHE »

My concern is lack of current limiting from battery through the primary side of the ignition coil.

Re: condenser, I don't know. The coil works to continue current flowing when the switch is broken but ultimately dumps it's field in the secondary. Maybe the condenser forces this to occur quicker?
dcarver
Contributor
Veteran
Posts: 1018
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2013 12:18 am
FJRModel: Gen2, Superior 2006, Gen 3 2013 twice as good!
x 120
x 1542

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by dcarver »

raYzerman wrote: Tue Jun 11, 2024 9:12 pm Don't know anything.... but assuming the KZ does not have a condenser or points ignition, like an old Honda I just got.
Question, you've got the wires directly to the plugs...... are there not spark plug adapters, and don't they have a resistance of like 5k ohms?? I don't know if that is an issue or not.......
I don't know either, but good observation. I do have some 5k caps around.. worth a try! The KZ runs electronically, not mechanically. 3 pick up coils to provide pulse, an 'ignitor' that's 3 Darlington transistors, then 3 coils.
dcarver
Contributor
Veteran
Posts: 1018
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2013 12:18 am
FJRModel: Gen2, Superior 2006, Gen 3 2013 twice as good!
x 120
x 1542

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by dcarver »

N4HHE wrote: Tue Jun 11, 2024 11:54 pm My concern is lack of current limiting from battery through the primary side of the ignition coil.

Re: condenser, I don't know. The coil works to continue current flowing when the switch is broken but ultimately dumps it's field in the secondary. Maybe the condenser forces this to occur quicker?
Overheating the coil can happen if powered on continuously. I saw a video to prove it :D . On the bench, cycle the switch on and off as fast as my fingers can.

Hopefully I’m doing the math correctly here.. If coil primary is charging (putting winding under stress) every 6.2 milliseconds, then discharging (winding not stressed) for 1.3 milliseconds then the primary winding duty cycle is 79%. 100-(1.3/6.2*100) A 3 ohm resistance at 13 volts draws 4 amps (13 volts / 3 ohms). I’m simply having difficulty understanding how a 1 second power toggle could harm the primary winding.
N4HHE
Veteran
Posts: 2152
Joined: Thu Mar 08, 2018 10:17 pm
FJRModel: 2016
Location: North Alabama
x 3611
x 1975

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by N4HHE »

As an amateur radio operator I am kicking myself for not realizing a coil and a capacitor in parallel is a resonate circuit.
User avatar
raYzerman
Contributor
I post more than I ride
Posts: 9573
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 10:49 am
FJRModel: 2010 Honda CBF1000FA
Location: Millgrove, Ontario, CA
x 3085
x 11377

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by raYzerman »

I'm learning stuff.... reading up on a little Honda I just got, has points and condenser ignition..... you need the condenser if you're direct like all your hookups.... electronic ignition systems can eliminate both or as one guy has developed.... keep the points and eliminate the condensers.
As for resistance, if you have resistor plugs you don't need resistor caps, but 5 k resistor caps can be used with resistor plugs, and must be used with non-resistor plugs.... or so I'm reading. The resistors just keep the static offa yer AM radio.
Keep yer stick on the ice........... (Red Green)
Duct tape can't fix stupid, but it can sure muffle the sound.
dcarver
Contributor
Veteran
Posts: 1018
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2013 12:18 am
FJRModel: Gen2, Superior 2006, Gen 3 2013 twice as good!
x 120
x 1542

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by dcarver »

N4HHE wrote: Fri Jun 14, 2024 8:30 pm As an amateur radio operator I am kicking myself for not realizing a coil and a capacitor in parallel is a resonate circuit.
Reading, this is an LC Tank circuit? How does this impact, or does it affect the wasted spark test config on my bench? Thanks in Advance, learning.
dcarver
Contributor
Veteran
Posts: 1018
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2013 12:18 am
FJRModel: Gen2, Superior 2006, Gen 3 2013 twice as good!
x 120
x 1542

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by dcarver »

raYzerman wrote: Fri Jun 14, 2024 10:18 pm I'm learning stuff.... reading up on a little Honda I just got, has points and condenser ignition..... you need the condenser if you're direct like all your hookups.... electronic ignition systems can eliminate both or as one guy has developed.... keep the points and eliminate the condensers.
As for resistance, if you have resistor plugs you don't need resistor caps, but 5 k resistor caps can be used with resistor plugs, and must be used with non-resistor plugs.... or so I'm reading. The resistors just keep the static offa yer AM radio.
Yeah, me too. Been YEARS since I studied DC/AC theory in JC. Forgot most of it. Yes, these are resistor plugs.
Here's a good video showing the impact the condenser has to save points.
https://youtu.be/MQtMtvf5a4E

D
User avatar
raYzerman
Contributor
I post more than I ride
Posts: 9573
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 10:49 am
FJRModel: 2010 Honda CBF1000FA
Location: Millgrove, Ontario, CA
x 3085
x 11377

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by raYzerman »

So essentially you need the condenser in your test setup..... now for the switching, maybe fab up a plate with a set of points and a hex nut for a cam to operate them? Or find an old distributor...... however, what do you need to know at this point, the coils are working!
Keep yer stick on the ice........... (Red Green)
Duct tape can't fix stupid, but it can sure muffle the sound.
User avatar
Road Runner
Veteran
Posts: 459
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2019 9:10 pm
FJRModel: 2008 FJR Advanced Edition
1987 KLR 650 Thumper
Location: Saratoga, NY. area
x 1717
x 835

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by Road Runner »

Yes, it looks like coils are working so not the problem. Are the coils getting good voltage on the bike? Is it Battery or Magneto ignition system?
"A biker never knows" - Tim Allen


Art
dcarver
Contributor
Veteran
Posts: 1018
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2013 12:18 am
FJRModel: Gen2, Superior 2006, Gen 3 2013 twice as good!
x 120
x 1542

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by dcarver »

raYzerman wrote: Sat Jun 15, 2024 8:12 pm So essentially you need the condenser in your test setup..... now for the switching, maybe fab up a plate with a set of points and a hex nut for a cam to operate them? Or find an old distributor...... however, what do you need to know at this point, the coils are working!
I found this coil tester and ordered it. It also can test most any device requiring a pulse. Stepper motors, fuel injectors, etc.
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0CZ8 ... UTF8&psc=1
dcarver
Contributor
Veteran
Posts: 1018
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2013 12:18 am
FJRModel: Gen2, Superior 2006, Gen 3 2013 twice as good!
x 120
x 1542

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by dcarver »

Road Runner wrote: Sun Jun 16, 2024 7:21 am Yes, it looks like coils are working so not the problem. Are the coils getting good voltage on the bike? Is it Battery or Magneto ignition system?
When battery is at 13.8, coils are seeing 13.5. Coil resistances are matched to keep the ignitor (3 Darlington transistors) happy. Also performed the FSM pick up coil test, all 3 are SAT. Did read where one guy sent power direct from key on relay to coils for max voltage. His other option was replace the 45 year old wiring harness which is $$$.

Can't wait for the tester to get here!
User avatar
Road Runner
Veteran
Posts: 459
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2019 9:10 pm
FJRModel: 2008 FJR Advanced Edition
1987 KLR 650 Thumper
Location: Saratoga, NY. area
x 1717
x 835

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by Road Runner »

Maybe your spark is fine and something else is wrong.
What are symptoms?
"A biker never knows" - Tim Allen


Art
dcarver
Contributor
Veteran
Posts: 1018
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2013 12:18 am
FJRModel: Gen2, Superior 2006, Gen 3 2013 twice as good!
x 120
x 1542

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by dcarver »

Road Runner wrote: Sun Jun 16, 2024 2:43 pm Maybe your spark is fine and something else is wrong.
What are symptoms?
The bike runs, but sputters and is missing. Carbs were professionally rebuilt (although should have done them myself, in hindsight).

Installed new ignition aftermarket coils which eliminated the ballast resistor which is a known failure point that will burn out the Ignitor module.

When I place the plugs on the cylinder head and crank, I have very little visible spark.. As in, are they sparking? Cover to help eliminate daylight, still can't really tell if spark is there. As compared to my FJR's where I can easily see spark, even in direct daylight.
User avatar
Road Runner
Veteran
Posts: 459
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2019 9:10 pm
FJRModel: 2008 FJR Advanced Edition
1987 KLR 650 Thumper
Location: Saratoga, NY. area
x 1717
x 835

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by Road Runner »

dcarver wrote: Sun Jun 16, 2024 3:54 pm
Road Runner wrote: Sun Jun 16, 2024 2:43 pm Maybe your spark is fine and something else is wrong.
What are symptoms?
The bike runs, but sputters and is missing. Carbs were professionally rebuilt (although should have done them myself, in hindsight).

Installed new ignition aftermarket coils which eliminated the ballast resistor which is a known failure point that will burn out the Ignitor module.

When I place the plugs on the cylinder head and crank, I have very little visible spark.. As in, are they sparking? Cover to help eliminate daylight, still can't really tell if spark is there. As compared to my FJR's where I can easily see spark, even in direct daylight.
Are the plug wires and ends OK?
Did swapping the coils make any difference?
"A biker never knows" - Tim Allen


Art
dcarver
Contributor
Veteran
Posts: 1018
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2013 12:18 am
FJRModel: Gen2, Superior 2006, Gen 3 2013 twice as good!
x 120
x 1542

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by dcarver »

Road Runner wrote: Sun Jun 16, 2024 9:31 pm
dcarver wrote: Sun Jun 16, 2024 3:54 pm
Road Runner wrote: Sun Jun 16, 2024 2:43 pm Maybe your spark is fine and something else is wrong.
What are symptoms?
The bike runs, but sputters and is missing. Carbs were professionally rebuilt (although should have done them myself, in hindsight).

Installed new ignition aftermarket coils which eliminated the ballast resistor which is a known failure point that will burn out the Ignitor module.

When I place the plugs on the cylinder head and crank, I have very little visible spark.. As in, are they sparking? Cover to help eliminate daylight, still can't really tell if spark is there. As compared to my FJR's where I can easily see spark, even in direct daylight.
Are the plug wires and ends OK?
Did swapping the coils make any difference?
Bike was running with old Martek aftermarket coils. Bought new coils from YellowSquare. New wires, new caps, new plugs. The new coil allowed eliminating the ballast resistor, a known failure point. With new coils, bike ran good for about 30 seconds then started bucking and farting. That's when I checked for spark and found very weak spark.
User avatar
Road Runner
Veteran
Posts: 459
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2019 9:10 pm
FJRModel: 2008 FJR Advanced Edition
1987 KLR 650 Thumper
Location: Saratoga, NY. area
x 1717
x 835

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by Road Runner »

Does it run good with old coils? If so, there's the problem. If not, then need to dig further. Then ohm check charge coils, trigger coils, Ignition coils.
"A biker never knows" - Tim Allen


Art
User avatar
raYzerman
Contributor
I post more than I ride
Posts: 9573
Joined: Mon Mar 18, 2013 10:49 am
FJRModel: 2010 Honda CBF1000FA
Location: Millgrove, Ontario, CA
x 3085
x 11377

Re: ?? Bench Testing Ignition Coils ??

Post by raYzerman »

You mention the KZ has igniters... I don't know anything about igniters, but had them on my old Magna, and bought spare set. Any spares to play with? These days, aftermarket replacements might be available.
And perhaps put your old coils to the test setup you had, see if they sparkie well, then perhaps the bike's system is the issue?
Keep yer stick on the ice........... (Red Green)
Duct tape can't fix stupid, but it can sure muffle the sound.
Post Reply